Showing posts with label UK. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UK. Show all posts

14 August 2025

European Patent Applications from the UK in 2024

European Patent Office, Munich
Author Carsten Steger  Licence  CC BY-SA 4.0   Source  Wikimedia Commons

 








Jane Lambert

The European Patent Office ("EPO") is the fifth-largest patent office in the world.   The other four are the China National Intellectual Property Administration, the United States Patent and Trademark Office, the Japan Patent Office and the Korea Intellectual Property Office.  The EPO grants patents for the territories of its contracting parties on behalf of their governments.  The United Kingdom is one of those parties.  A patent granted by the EPO designating the UK (known as a "European patent (UK)") is treated as equivalent to a patent granted by the Intellectual Property Office in Newport for all practical purposes.

According to EPO figures published earlier this year, there were 6,076 applications from the United Kingdom in 2024.  That was an increase of 3.1% over the previous year, and it placed this country 9th in the list of countries of origin for European patent applications.   The countries ahead of us were the United States with 47,787 European patent applications, Germany with 25,033, Japan with 21,062, China with 20,081, South Korea with 13,107,  France with 10,980, Switzerland with 9,966 and the Netherlands with 7,054.  Immediately behind the UK was Sweden with 4,936 applications.  Italy was 11th with 4,853, and Spain was 15th with 2,192.  In the top 10 countries of origin, only South Korea and Switzerland exceeded the UK's percentage increase in European patent applications, though Hong Kong and Norway, which are further down the list, saw double-digit percentage increases.

Britain's 3.1% uptick is less impressive when the number of European patent applications per country is compared to its population.   Switzerland produced  1,112.8 applications per million inhabitants.   It was followed by Sweden with 467.79, Finland with 428.28 and Denmark with 425.92. With 87,88 applications per million, this country came 18th in the list which is surprising for the country that pioneered the industrial revolution and has some of the finest universities in the world.

The following graphic shows the fields for which applications from the UK were filed in 2024.











Consumer goods came top, followed by computers, med-tech and biotech.   The top 10 applicants were as follows:

British American Tobacco Plc636
Unilever Plc613
Rolls-Royce Plc254
BAE Systems Plc184
British Telecommunications Plc175
Linde Plc173
Imperial Brands Plc140
AstraZeneca Plc121
Shell Plc116
Johnson Matthey Inc.105

One of the reasons why the UK has underperformed its competitors in patenting was thought to be the risk and costs of IP enforcement.   The Arnold reforms which I discussed in New Patents County Court Rules on 31 Oct 2010 NIPC Law, were intended to be an answer to that problem.  It seems to be taking a long time for news that IP enforcement need not be ruinously risky and expensive to filter down to industry.

Small and medium enterprises can protect themselves against such risk and cost by taking out IP insurance cover.  The Intellectual Property Office has published useful Guidance on Intellectual Property Insurance, and the Chartered Institute of Patent Attorneys maintains a comprehensive list of brokers, underwriters and insurers on its website.

Anyone wishing to discuss this article may call me on +44 (0)20 7404 5252 during normal office hours or send me a message through my contact form at any time.

10 November 2024

European Universities' Patenting Activity


 





















Jane Lambert

In October 2024 the European Patent Office published The Role of European Universities in Patenting and Innovation, A Study of Academic Inventions at the EPO.  The study claims to be "the first-ever comprehensive overview of the role European universities play in patenting and innovation on the European scale." 

The study notes that Europe is often perceived as a world-class academic power with top universities and publications. Europe faces difficulties transforming science into commercial activity compared to other advanced economies. The mismatch between academic excellence and commercial underperformance is sometimes called the 'European paradox'. The study states that this so-called European paradox has become a central policy issue in most European countries and also for the EU.

The study focuses on European universities' patenting activity as a way of addressing that paradox because a patent is essential to knowledge transfer. That is because an applicant for a patent is required by art 83 of the European Patent Convention to disclose the invention in a manner sufficiently clear and complete for it to be carried out by a person skilled in the art.   

One of the study's key findings is that the contribution of academic researchers to European patent applications has increased steadily in recent decades, and now exceeds 10% of all patents filed by European applicants at the EPO. The study finds that more than 1,200 European universities have generated patent applications at the EPO. Annex 2 to the study lists the top 10 universities for Germany, France and the UK and the top 5 for other countries between the years 2000 and 2020. There are 7 universities with over 1,000 academic patents in Germany, 6 in France and 4 in the UK (Oxford, Cambridge, Imperial and UCL). Denmark, Sweden and Switzerland have 2 such universities each and Belgium, Finland and the Netherlands one each.

It is undeniably a good thing that knowledge is widely disseminated while being properly protected it has to be remembered that universities are not businesses though most have knowledge transfer offices and licensing companies.  It is my experience that they occasionally claim greater legal protection than they need or in some cases to which they are entitled to the detriment of the businesses that pay for the research,  
 
Any business contemplating research cooperation with a British university should seek advice either from a patent attorney or a solicitor or counsel specializing in IP with experience in licensing.  The Intellectual Property Office publishes several model university and business collaboration agreements known as "the Lambert toolkit".  The name of the toolkit refers to Sir Richard Lambert and not to me though I did attend one of the drafting sessions and thus made a small contribution towards their drafting.

Anyone wishing to discuss this article may call me on +44 (0)20 7404n 5252 during UK office hours or send me a message through my contact form at all other times.

03 September 2021

The Border Innovation Hub

White Cliffs of Dover
Author Immanuel Giel Licence CC BY-SA 3.0  Source Wikimedia Commons

 











Jane Lambert

In UK Innovation Strategy I discussed ways in which the British government proposed to stimulate innovation so that the UK could join China, the USA, Japan and South Korea as a science and technology superpower by 2039,  Buried away in the text on free ports  on page 78 was this reference to the UK border:

"The innovation activity in Freeports will build on the government’s 2025 UK Border Strategy, published in December 2020, which set out a Technology and Innovation roadmap to drive forward innovation at the UK border."

 The 2025 UK Border Strategy mentioned in that sentence provided for private sector participation "to design, deliver and innovate around the border."

That strategy aims to achieve 6 "transformations:"

  1. "Develop a coordinated user-centric government approach to border design and delivery, which works in partnership with industry and enables border innovation. 
  2. Bring together government’s collection, assurance and use of border data to provide a comprehensive and holistic view of data at the border. 
  3. Establish resilient ‘ports of the future’ at border crossing points to make the experience smoother and more secure for passengers and traders, while better protecting the public and environment. 
  4. Use upstream compliance to move processes away from the actual frontier where appropriate, both for passengers and traders. 
  5. Build the capability of staff and the border industry responsible for delivering border processes, particularly in an environment of greater automation; and simplify communication with border users to improve their experience. 
  6. Shape the future development of borders worldwide, to promote the UK’s interests and facilitate end-to-end trade and travel."

The 4th of those "transformations" is reminiscent of arguments of the Democratic Unionist and the European Research Group politicians against regulatory alignment or the Northern Ireland protocol during the EU withdrawal agreement negotiations on the ground that it ought to be possible to avoid checks and inspections at the geographical frontier between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic by carrying them out elsewhere with the appropriate technology.

Whether or not the hope of renegotiating the Northern Irish protocol is the motivation for its interest in the topic or merely coincidental, the Cabinet Office published its "Border Innovation Hub" on 31 Aug 2021 together with a Technology and Innovation Roadmap, a list of APIs (Application Programming Interfaces) and guidance on Opportunities and Funding.   The purpose of the Hub is said to bring "together information from across government to help provide industry with the tools needed to innovate at the border."  The overview states that 
"Technology and innovation to unlock new possibilities for smoother and safer border processes is a key element of the new strategy."

Further information about how the government hopes to achieve that objective is set out in the Roadmap.

The Roadmap is taken from the  2025 UK Border Strategy and includes the following:

  • "Create a visible first point of contact in UK Government for border innovation suppliers and users"
  • "Define target use cases with industry.
  • "Set and collate security and interoperability standards," and
  • "Work across government to design the border and support border innovation and its uptake."
The "first point of contact" mentioned above is the "Border Innovation Hub". 

Possible funders for research and development work by industry include the Defence and Security Accelerator, the Connected Places Catapult,  Transport Research and Innovation Grants and Innovate UK.

Any inventions resulting from border innovation would be patentable subject to the provisions of the Defence Contracts Act 1958.  The names of businesses, products and services might be registrable trade marks.  Anything written down would be protected from copying by copyright.  Any commercially sensitive unpublished research could be confidential.   Anyone wishing to discuss those matters should contact me on 020 7404 5252 or send me a message through my contact form.

12 August 2021

UK Innovation Strategy

Standard YouTube Licence


In his foreword to Global Britain in a competitive age which I discussed in NIPC Brexit on 19 March 2021, the Prime Minister wrote: "Our aim is to have secured our status as a Science and Tech Superpower by 2030." The Secretary of State for Business referred to that target in his foreword to UK Innovation Strategy Leading the future by creating it.  In my article, I wrote:
"As an intellectual property lawyer, I should love to see the UK become a science and technology superpower with vibrant creative industries attracting investment and expertise from around the world.   I just can't see how it is going to happen,"

I read the UK Innovation Strategy very carefully in the hope that it would explain how the UK will become a science and tech superpower in 9 years.

Synopsis

The document is 116 pages long divided as follow:  

  • Secretary of State's Foreword (pages 4-5);
  • "At a glance":  a bulleted list of the steps that the government proposes to take (page 6);
  • "Introduction:  Why do we need an Innovation Strategy?":  a summary of the strategy (pages 7 - 10);
  • Part 1 "Innovation today" covering "What is innovation?", "Why is innovation important?", "The challenge: Innovation created the modern world, but progress is slowing" and "The opportunity: The UK is ideally placed to lead a renewed global spirit of innovation" (pages 11 to 17);
  • Part 2 " Innovation tomorrow" covering "Learning from the pandemic to create the world’s best innovation ecosystem", "Vision 2035: The UK as a global hub for innovation" and "Tracking progress towards our vision" (pages 18 - 21);
  • Part 3: "Achieving Vision 2035" covering "Pillar 1: Unleashing Business – We will fuel businesses who want to innovate", "Pillar 2: People – We will make the UK the most exciting place for innovation talent", "Pillar 3: Institutions & Places – We will ensure our research, development & innovation institutions serve the needs of businesses and places across the UK" and "Pillar 4: Missions & Technologies – We will stimulate innovation to tackle major challenges faced by the UK and the world and drive capability in key technologies! (pages 18 - 100);
  • Part 4: "Achieving our ambitions – implementation and next steps" (pages 101 - 107);
  • Annex A "Innovation institutions" (pages 108 - 113) and
  • Annex B: "List of Stakeholders Consulted" (pages 114 and 115).

Becoming a "Science and Rech Superpower" in Nine Years

The Introduction states on page 8:
"The Prime Minister has announced our intention to be a science superpower by 2030, placing science, innovation and technology at the heart of his vision for the UK. This involves being to science and technology what we are to finance: a central hub of the global economy, and the country that the world’s most innovative people and firms make their home."

Although there are signs that it has lost some business to Amsterdam, Dublin, Frankfurt, Madrid, Milan and Paris as a result of the UK's departure from the European Union, London remains one of the world's leading financial centres rivalled only by New York, Shanghai, Hong Kong and Singapore (see The Global Financial Centres Index 29  Long Finance. March 2021. Retrieved 18 March 2021).

A good measure of scientific and technical activity is the number of patent applications sought in a year.  According to the World Intellectual Property Indicators for 2019 published by the World Intellectual Property Organization, applicants in China applied for more than 1.5 million parents from the world's top 20 patent offices in 2018.  The United States came second with 597,141. Japan followed with 313,567 and South Korea came fourth with 209,992.  Companies from those countries. Huawei, Mitsubishi, Samsung, Qualcomm and Oppo, were among the top 5 applicants.  China, the USA, Japan and South Korea can fairly be regarded as scientific and technical superpowers.   If the UK is to be in science and technology what it is in finance it should aspire to create a similar number of patentable inventions by 2030.

With 29,941 patent applications in the world's top 20 parent offices, the UK lay number 13th.  It was ahead of Mexico but behind Taiwan, Germany, India, Russia, Canada, Australia and Brazil.   If the UK is to leapfrog over all those countries to join the USA, China, Japan and South Korea as a scientific and technical superpower it has a lot of work to do.

The government acknowledges the magnitude of that task on page 18 in the section headed "The opportunity: The UK is ideally placed to lead a renewed global spirit of innovation":

  • "Business investment in R&D has fallen relative to our international peers. 
  • There are low rates of technology adoption by firms that lead to underutilised knowledge. 
  • We are at risk of a ‘brain drain’, the UK being a net exporter of talent. 
  • Our workforce has skills gaps in some key areas which are at risk of growing in the coming years. 
  • Our regulatory system often favours incumbent businesses over innovative new ones. 
  • Growth is increasingly due to consumption, not due to investment. 
  • Data, research and IP must be safeguarded to maintain competitiveness."

 Learning from the Pandemic

Part 2 of the UK Innovation Strategy points to the development of the Oxford/Astra-Zenica vaccine and other medical technologies in response to the pandemic as examples of British scientific and technical prowess and indicators of the way forward to superpower status. The speed with which the Oxford/Astra-Zenica vaccine had been developed and deployed was indeed a substantial achievement despite criticism of its effectiveness and side effects and the delay in obtaining regulatory approval in the USA.   However, similar success has been achieved elsewhere.  China has developed 7 vaccines that have achieved regulatory approval.  Russia has developed another 4.  The USA another 3 although the Pfizer–BioNTech and Janssen or Johnson & Johnson were developed in collaboration with German and Dutch scientists.  Two vaccines have also been developed by Cuba.  Others have been developed by India, Iran, Kazakhstan and Taiwan,

The Four Pillars

On page 21, the UK Industrial Strategy states that the government has four objectives it refers to as ‘Pillars’ in the document:
  • "Pillar 1: Unleashing business – We will fuel businesses who want to innovate. 
  • Pillar 2: People – We will make the UK the most exciting place for innovation talent. 
  • Pillar 3: Institutions & Places – We will ensure our research, development & innovation institutions serve the needs of businesses and places across the UK. 
  • Pillar 4: Missions & Technologies – We will stimulate innovation to tackle major challenges faced by the UK and the world and drive capability in key technologies."

These are amplified in  "At a glance" on page 6:

"Pillar 1: Unleashing Business – We will fuel businesses who want to innovate.

  • Increase annual public investment on R&D to a record £22 billion. 
  • Reduce complexity for innovative companies by developing an online finance and innovation hub between Innovate UK and the British Business Bank. 
  • Invest £200 million through the British Business Bank’s Life Sciences Investment Programme to target the growth-stage funding gap faced by UK life science companies. 
  • Consult on how regulation can ensure that the UK is well-placed to extract the best value from innovation. 
  • Form a new Business Innovation Forum to drive implementation of this Strategy.
  •  Pillar 2: People – We will make the UK the most exciting place for innovation talent. 

  • Introduce new High Potential Individual and Scale-up visa routes, and revitalise the Innovator route to attract and retain high-skilled, globally mobile innovation talent. 
  • Support, through Help to Grow: Management, 30,000 senior managers of small and medium-sized firms to boost their business’ performance, resilience, and growth. 
Pillar 3: Institutions & Places – We will ensure our research, development and innovation institutions serve the needs of businesses and places across the UK.  
  • Undertake an independent review, led by Nobel Laureate Professor Sir Paul Nurse, Director of the Francis Crick Institute, looking across the landscape of UK organisations undertaking all forms of research, development and innovation. 
  • Allocate £127 million through the Strength in Places Fund to develop R&D capacity and support local growth across the UK. 
  • Invest £25 million of funding to the Connecting Capability Fund to help drive economic growth through university-business innovation. 
Pillar 4: Missions & Technologies – We will stimulate innovation to tackle major challenges faced by the UK and the world and drive capability in key technologies.  
  • Establish a new Innovation Missions programme to tackle some of the most significant issues confronting the UK and the world in the coming years. 
  • Identify the key seven technology families that will transform our economy in the future.
  • Launch new Prosperity Partnerships to establish business-led research projects to develop transformational new technologies, with £59 million of industry, university and government investment."

Those  "pillars" are addressed in more detail in Part 3 and repeated for good measure in Part IV. 

Intellectual Property

One of the reasons why there are relatively few patent applications from businesses in the UK is the high cost of prosecution and enforcement.  

In 2004 the European Patent Office commissioned Roland Berger Market Research to compare the cost of patenting an invention in the UK and 5 other countries with the cost of patenting it in the USA and Japan (see my article Cost of Patents: EPO Report tells us what most of us already knew 23 Dec 2005).   In its Study on the Cost of Patenting Roland Berger reported that the cost of patenting an invention consisting of 10 claims on 3 pages, 11 pages of description designating 6 countries including the UK would be €30,530.  The cost of patenting the same invention would be €24,100 in the USA and €5,460 in Japan.  The cost of patenting in Europe may have fallen as a result of the Agreement on the application of Article 65 of the Convention on the Grant of European Patents in London (OJ EPO p 560 12 Feb 2001) but it is still believed to be higher than in the USA and Japan.

According to TaylorWessing's Patent Map. the typical costs of an infringement claim are between £200,000 and £1 million in England, €200,000 - €800,000 in France, €100,000 - €200,000 on infringement and a similar amount on validity in Germany, €75,000 - €200,000 in the Netherlands and  €2,530 - €375,000 in Switzerland.   The costs of litigation in the USA will be at least as much as in England because it is also a common law country but it is unusual for lawyers' fees to be awarded against the unsuccessful party.  It is arguable that England is the most expensive and possibly the riskiest jurisdiction in the world in which to enforce an intellectual property right.

Governments of both parties have been aware of this problem for at least the last 20 years (see DTI Innovation Report Competing in The Global Economy: The Innovation Challenge 1 Dec 2003).  They have also been aware of the solution which was an EU patent to be enforced by an EU patent court.  It is for that reason that the UK ratified the Community Patent Convention in 1975. It supported proposals for a Litigation Protocol to the European Patent Convention, a regulation for an EU patent and later the agreement for a unitary patent.  Even after the 2016 referendum, the government believed it would be possible to remain party to the agreement.  Mr Boris Johnspn in his capacity as Foreign Secretary actually deposited the UK's instrument of ratification on 26 April 2018.   Sadly, Amanda Solway MP gave notice of British withdrawal from the Unified Patent Court Agreement just over a year ago (see UK Withdrawal from the UPCA 20 July 2020).

As I argued in Has the Volte-Face on the Unified Patent Court Agreement been worth it? in NIPC Brexit on 6 April 2021 and in other articles, the sudden reversal by Amanda Solway of a longstanding policy on a unitary patent did British industry and science no favours.  It has perpetuated the disincentive to patent in this country.   Without adequate legal protection for innovation, investment in research and development can be expected to diminish.

The government might have been expected to respond that withdrawal from the Unified Patent Court Agreement was a necessary consequence of Brexit and that losses resulting from withdrawing from Europe will be more than offset by new opportunities elsewhere.  I looked carefully to see whether that was the case but I found nothing in the UK Innovation Strategy to suggest that it was.  Though the Intellectual Property Office published a press release on 29 July 2021 promising that IP was at the heart of the new innovation strategy, there is very mention of IP at all.  The word "patent" occurs twice in the document's 116 pages and there are a few paragraphs under the heading "Safeguarding Intellectual Property" on pages 39 and 40.  There is nothing in those paragraphs on reducing the cost of patenting or the cost of enforcing intellectual property rights.

I am not the only commentator to spot that lacuna.   Graeme Moore wrote in his comment New Innovation Strategy for the UK for The Patent Lawyer Magazine:

"However, there is a major factor that the UK government’s announcement fails to address satisfactorily – how to better protect the innovations developed in the UK from being copied and exploited by other companies who have not invested in the innovations? This should be at the forefront of the UK government’s mind when committing to spend UK taxpayers’ money on R&D – it’s a key part of ensuring a return on investment."

Conclusion

There are announcements to be welcomed in the Strategy such as the spending promises in Piller 1 and the "new High Potential Individual and Scale-up visa routes" in Pillar 2.  But the idea that British companies will be competing with the likes of Huawei, Mitsubishi and Samsung in such fields as artificial intelligence,  mobile telecoms, consumer electronics or any other new technology is as fanciful as the garden bridge, an airport in the Thames estuary and a bridge to Northern Ireland.  

Anyone wishing to discuss this article can call me on 020 7404 5252b during office hours or send me a message through my contact form,

25 July 2014

UK slumps to Ninth Place in European Patent Applications

According to the European Patent Office the UK has slumped from fifth place in the number of applications for European patents in 2004 to ninth in 2013. There were 6,469 European patent filings from the UK in 2013 which was an increase of just 7 from the 6,462 in 2004. By contrast, there 32,022 from Germany compared to 28,221 in 2004 and 12,417 from France in 2013 compared to 9,656 in 2004. But the real growth in applications has come from China (22,292 in 2013 compared to 1,880 in 2004) and South Korea (16,857 in 2013 compared to 5,721 in 2004).

For a more complete picture I have compiled the following table of the top 10 applicant countries based on European Patent Office data:

Country
2012
2013
USA
63,198
64,967
Japan
51,791
52,437
Germany
33,850
32,022
China
19,182
22,292
South Korea
14,791
16,857
France
12,285
12,417
Switzerland
8,129
7,966
Netherlands
6,489
7,606
UK
6,666
6,469
Sweden
4.654
5.094

The UK's performance is even more depressing when the number of applications per million inhabitants are taken into consideration (see the table on page 15 of Facts and Figures for 2014 that can be downloaded from the "Publications" page of the EPO website). The UK comes 16th in that league with 72 European patent applications per million inhabitants.  Top of the list is Switzerland with 832 European patent applications per million inhabitants followed by Sweden (402), Finland (360), Denmark (347), Netherlands (347) and Germany (328). Japan comes 9th with 177 European patent applications per million inhabitants, France 10th with 148, South Korea 12th with 129, the Republic of Ireland 13th with 115 and the USA 15th with 107.

Why does the UK do so badly in the number of applications to its home patent office in comparison with its global competitors? I used to think that it was because of the high cost of enforcement in the UK compared to France, Germany and the Netherlands. The rule changes limiting the costs and duration of proceedings in the Patents County Court (now IPEC) in October 2010 addressed that problem but  the number of European patent filings from the UK has actually fallen from 7,146 in 2010 to 6,469 in 2013.

Paradoxically a report by Silicon Valley Bank on Innovation Economy Outlook 2014 published this week paints a rather rosy picture for the UK. This report may well contain the answer. Much of the UK's growth has been in the service sector, especially financial and professional services and information technology for which patents are not available. Manufacturing in the UK is less important than it is in our continental and East Asian competitors.

If that is the explanation it suggests a failure of Coalition policy since 2010 to rebalance the British economy from one that is heavily dependent on services and the public sector to an economy based on manufacturing and exports.